Why is Desiccated Thyroid Not Recommended? - Live Forever Health
Close this search box.
Why is Desiccated Thyroid Not Recommended?
why is desiccated thyroid not recommended


Total Floor Area




Desiccated thyroid, often marketed as a ‘natural’ health-food thyroid preparation, has been a subject of controversy and concern within the medical community. As individuals seek alternative treatments for thyroid disorders, the use of desiccated thyroid has garnered attention. However, it is essential to delve into the reasons why this particular thyroid medication is not recommended by many healthcare professionals.

This article aims to explore the various aspects surrounding desiccated thyroid and shed light on the recommendations provided by reputable sources such as the Specialist Pharmacy Service (SPS) and the National Health Service (NHS). By understanding the concerns raised by healthcare authorities, individuals can make informed decisions about their thyroid health and consider alternative, evidence-based treatments. Now, let’s delve into the specifics of ‘natural’ desiccated thyroid and the reasons behind its lack of recommendation.

‘Natural’ Desiccated Thyroid: A ‘Health-Food’ Thyroid Preparation

Natural Desiccated Thyroid (NDT) is a thyroid hormone replacement medication derived from porcine thyroid glands. It is often referred to as a ‘health-food’ thyroid preparation due to its natural origin. NDT contains both thyroxine (T4) and triiodothyronine (T3), which are the two main hormones produced by the thyroid gland. Unlike synthetic thyroid medications that typically only contain T4, NDT aims to replicate the natural hormone balance found in the human body.

Key Features of Natural Desiccated Thyroid:

  1. Natural Origin: NDT is sourced from the thyroid glands of pigs, making it a naturally derived product. Some individuals may prefer this natural source over synthetic alternatives.
  2. T4 and T3 Combination: NDT contains both T4 and T3 hormones, providing a more comprehensive approach to thyroid hormone replacement. T4 is converted into the active form of T3 in the body, and NDT aims to provide both hormones directly.
  3. Bioavailability: Proponents of NDT argue that its natural composition may enhance bioavailability and improve the body’s ability to utilize thyroid hormones effectively.
  4. Potential Benefits: Some individuals using NDT report improved symptom control, including better energy levels, mood, and weight management. However, individual responses to thyroid medications can vary.

Specialist Pharmacy Service (SPS) and NHS Recommendations

In this section, we will explore the recommendations provided by the Specialist Pharmacy Service (SPS) and the National Health Service (NHS) regarding the use of desiccated thyroid extract.

  1. Guidance Integration: The SPS actively integrates its expertise with NHS guidelines to ensure that pharmacy services align with the broader healthcare strategy. This collaboration is particularly vital in areas such as thyroid management, where medication adherence and efficacy are critical components of patient care.
  2. Evidence-Based Practices: Both the SPS and the NHS prioritize evidence-based practices in healthcare. Medication recommendations are rooted in the latest clinical evidence and research findings. This ensures that patients receive treatments that are not only safe and effective but also aligned with current medical knowledge.
  3. Thyroid Medication Management: Within the realm of thyroid disorders, the SPS collaborates with the NHS to provide recommendations on medication management. This may encompass a range of thyroid medications, including synthetic and natural desiccated thyroid options, based on individual patient needs and clinical considerations.
  4. Patient-Centric Approach: Both the SPS and the NHS maintain a patient-centric approach, recognizing the importance of tailoring medication regimens to individual patient characteristics and preferences. This approach aims to enhance patient outcomes and satisfaction while ensuring the best possible management of thyroid conditions.
  5. Continual Education and Training: The SPS actively engages in continual education and training programs, ensuring that pharmacy professionals are well-versed in the latest NHS guidelines. This commitment to ongoing education enables pharmacists to provide accurate and up-to-date information to both healthcare providers and patients.
  6. Collaborative Decision-Making: The collaborative relationship between the SPS and the NHS extends to collaborative decision-making processes. This ensures that pharmacy services are aligned with the broader goals of the NHS, promoting a seamless and integrated healthcare experience for patients managing thyroid disorders.

About Desiccated Thyroid Extract

In this section, we will examine the composition and bioequivalence of desiccated thyroid extract (DTE) and contrast its characteristics with the established benefits of levothyroxine.

Composition and Bioequivalence:

Desiccated Thyroid Extract (DTE):

  • Desiccated thyroid extract is derived from animal thyroid glands and comprises a mixture of thyroid hormones. However, the challenge lies in maintaining consistent formulations due to natural variability.

Bioequivalence Concerns:

  • Ensuring bioequivalence with DTE can be challenging, as the potency may vary between batches. This inconsistency may result in unpredictable thyroid hormone levels, complicating effective treatment

Benefits of Levothyroxine:

Standardized Composition:

  • Levothyroxine, a synthetic thyroid hormone, offers a standardized and consistent composition. This reliability ensures that each dosage contains the intended amount of the hormone, promoting stability in thyroid management.

Bioequivalence Assurance:

  • The synthetic nature of levothyroxine guarantees bioequivalence, meaning the body can consistently absorb and utilize the medication. This predictability is crucial for maintaining a steady balance of thyroid hormones.

Clinical Effectiveness:

  • Levothyroxine has demonstrated clinical effectiveness in managing hypothyroidism. Numerous studies and clinical trials support its efficacy, making it a widely prescribed and trusted medication for thyroid disorders.

Understanding these distinctions between desiccated thyroid extract and levothyroxine is vital for individuals making decisions about their thyroid medication. The subsequent sections will explore recommended actions for prescribers in primary care and delve into clinical considerations that discourage the use of desiccated thyroid extract.

Actions for Prescribers in Primary Care

In this section, we will outline recommended actions for prescribers in primary care concerning the use of desiccated thyroid extract.

Requests for DTE Products:

  • When faced with patient requests for desiccated thyroid extract (DTE) products, engage in open and transparent communication.
  • Explain the potential challenges associated with DTE, such as variability in potency, and discuss alternative, more consistent thyroid medications like levothyroxine.
  • Consider addressing patient concerns and preferences while prioritizing evidence-based and standardized treatment options.

Switching from DTE Products:

  • When contemplating switching patients from desiccated thyroid extract to an alternative, discuss the reasons for the switch and provide detailed information on the chosen replacement, such as levothyroxine.
  • Ensure a gradual and monitored transition to maintain thyroid function stability during the switch.
  • Educate patients on the benefits of the new medication and address any concerns or questions they may have.

Conclusion: Navigating Thyroid Medication Choices

In conclusion, the debate over desiccated thyroid extract (DTE) versus synthetic thyroid medications reflects a nuanced landscape in thyroid management. This article has explored key aspects influencing the recommendation against desiccated thyroid extract, as highlighted by healthcare authorities, clinical considerations, and expert opinions.

The insights shared by medical professionals underscore the challenges posed by the variability in DTE formulations, leading to concerns about inconsistent dosages and potential allergens. Research studies consistently support the standardized nature of synthetic alternatives, such as levothyroxine, emphasizing their reliability and efficacy in managing thyroid disorders.

While recognizing the individuality of patient experiences and the reported successes with desiccated thyroid extract, the medical community leans towards evidence-based, standardized treatments. The importance of licensed medications, backed by robust scientific research, is a cornerstone in thyroid care.

In navigating thyroid medication choices, individuals are encouraged to engage in open discussions with their healthcare providers. Understanding the considerations presented in this article can empower patients and prescribers alike to make informed decisions that prioritize both patient preferences and evidence-based practices.

Ultimately, the journey toward optimal thyroid health involves collaborative decision-making, where the synthesis of patient experiences and medical expertise leads to tailored and effective treatment plans.

Consider visiting Live Forever Lab for personalized treatment solutions.

More Projects